Gainsight Sells the Net Retention Playbook. Nick Mehta Applies It to Gainsight
110% is very good, 120% is really good, 130% is awesome — unless you're a consumption business, in which case Snowflake is at 180%. Gainsight's CEO on the number he sells.
On this page
Nick Mehta will tell you what good net revenue retention looks like, and then tell you not to compare yourself to the company at the top of the list.
Don’t compare yourself to Snowflake, because honestly it’ll just make you feel bad. That’s a different business model.
Nick Mehta, CEO, Gainsight
The thesis. Gainsight sells the software companies use to improve net revenue retention, so Mehta has an unusually complete map of what the number means across business models. Applied to Gainsight itself, that map explains both why the company was worth $1.1 billion to Vista and why it was never going to be worth more.
The benchmarks, from the company that watches them
Asked what world-class net dollar retention looks like for a company scaling from $10M to $50M, Mehta splits the answer in two before giving it. There is your operations — sales, customer success, his world. And there is your business model, which sets the ceiling before anyone does anything.
150% to 180%. Snowflake sits at 180%. The customer’s own usage does the expanding.
“110 is very good, 120 is really good, 130 is like awesome.”
100% is good. “HubSpot I think is about 101 and that’s amazing, and they’re doing a great job.”
All figures as Mehta states themGainsight published a report correlating public SaaS net retention against valuation multiple, which is the argument underneath all of it: the number is, in Mehta’s words, “the number one valuation driver in SaaS.”
Latka pushes the obvious follow-up — if consumption businesses get the best multiples, shouldn’t everyone move to usage pricing? Mehta’s answer is the best line in either conversation.
Shouldn’t every basketball player that is starting on the court be LeBron James?
Some businesses lend themselves to it and some do not, and he is explicit that Gainsight is not one of them. If you sell three-year enterprise contracts to a CHRO, “don’t even waste time on that, that’s a total waste of time — what you should figure out is how do you sell more modules.”
Which is exactly what Gainsight did
Gainsight created the customer success category. The point product answered one question: which customers should a CSM reach out to, and how do you spot risk. The reason companies have CSM teams at all is net retention — so the product had to widen.
To do that it’s not just about the CSM team, because you need the sales team to learn how to sell new things to your customers, and the product team needs to build products that are easy to adopt and use from the beginning.
The suite — Customer Cloud — has four parts: customer success, customer experience (surveys, NPS, natural language processing on the themes coming back), revenue optimisation (renewal forecasting, expansion, cross-sell identification), and product experience.
The product experience piece came from buying a company that had not really launched yet, after asking customers a single question.
What we heard from our clients over and over again when we asked, if we had a magic wand and we could do one thing to help drive net retention in your company — every CS leader said product. Every single one.
Mehta is candid that the shift itself was the hard part, more than any individual product: “it changes the way you market, the way you sell, the way you do planning, how you organise yourself. And we’re just figuring it out now — if people are listening and want to give me advice, I definitely would soak it up.”
The ladder
The GetLatka profile tracks it year by year: $100K in 2013, $1M in 2014, $5M in 2015, $16M in 2016, $30M in 2017, $48M in 2018, $67.2M in July 2019, $100M by the end of 2020.
The customer list is the who’s-who Mehta describes: Okta, Workday, Twilio, DocuSign, IBM, Adobe, Cisco, GE, ADP. The first ones were friends of friends — Marketo among them, and the person who ran customer success at Marketo was so taken with the product that he joined as one of Gainsight’s first executives.
Can’t recommend it enough, if you can have somebody in your company that’s been in the shoes of your buyer. The Marketo folks knew the Xactly folks, knew the Box folks. Once you have success in one place it helps build on itself, and that network is very tight.
Why the multiple was what it was
Vista bought a majority of Gainsight in November 2020 at a $1.1 billion valuation on $100 million of ARR. Latka puts it to him bluntly — many would argue that was a steal.
Mehta agrees, and then explains the arithmetic without flinching.
Our business was not like growing 70 or 80% a year. You went from 2019 $67 million run rate to 2020 $100 million — that’s pretty healthy growth, it’s good. But we weren’t at that like 100% growth.
He adds a structural caveat most comparisons miss: a Vista-type deal is 100% common stock, so the headline valuation is not comparable like-for-like against a venture round carrying a preference. And he concedes the timing.
We did it in November and the markets soared between November and March or April, so intellectually, honestly, I would have gone up a little bit more during that time frame. Timing could have been better on that front. But in the grand scheme of things that doesn’t matter that much to me.
What did matter was liquidity for people who had been there a long time — “an awesome opportunity for people to take care of their families” — and a partner comfortable with a company that grows well rather than explosively. Gainsight had raised roughly $155 million by 2019 and around $190 million by the Vista deal, from Battery, Bain Capital Ventures, Bessemer, Salesforce, Lightspeed, Insight and Summit.
What a category creator cannot look up
Mehta offers one piece of advice specifically for founders in a new category, and it comes from a question he could not answer.
If you are the market, if you’re creating the market, nobody else knows except you. So one of the things we do a lot of is look at primary data — Bain did a study for us and found that CSM teams are growing about 30% a year overall.
You cannot buy the industry report when you are the industry. You commission it.
The number he does not track
Post-Vista, Gainsight went from 700 employees at the start of 2021 to 900 by August — hiring more people that year than in its history — against the assumption that private equity means cost cutting. Around 17% of customers had bought the product experience module, which Mehta frames as the opportunity rather than the gap: “that means there’s 83 still to go buy it.”
Asked what he wishes he had known at twenty, he gives the standard answer first and then something else entirely — a card a friend had given him a few months earlier.
You are enough. You were born enough. Nothing you can ever do, nothing you can ever accomplish will change who you truly are. I still haven’t totally figured it out, but I think that’s what I try to tell myself every day.
Sources Nick Mehta’s interviews with Nathan Latka, recorded July 2019 and 18 August 2021; revenue, headcount and funding rows from the GetLatka Gainsight profile.
