Founder Interview
How Kit (Formerly ConvertKit) Reached $25M ARR While Staying Bootstrapped and Profitable (Interview with Founder and CEO Nathan Barry)
- Interview Date
- December 2, 2020
- Interviewee
- Nathan BarryFounder and CEO
Company Metrics at Interview Time
ARR (2020)
$25M
Profit Margin (2020)
5%
Affiliate Payouts (2020)
$250K per month
Paid Ads Spend (2020)
$400K per month
Commerce GMV (since mid-July 2020 private beta)
Almost $500K
Historical Snapshot
These numbers were reported by Nathan Barry during the interview recorded in December 2020 and are a historical snapshot, not current figures. See Kit (Formerly Convertkit)’s current numbers.

Key Takeaways
- 01ConvertKit reached $25M ARR in 2020, up from a $3.6M run rate in summer 2016
- 02Profit margin was about 5% in late 2020, down from close to 23% at the start of the year, as ConvertKit spent more aggressively
- 03The company paid out $250K per month to affiliates at a 30% commission rate
- 04Paid advertising spend reached $400K per month in 2020
- 05ConvertKit Commerce launched in mid-July 2020 private beta and processed almost $500K in GMV
- 06Search drove about 40% of all new accounts, while Powered By links sent 14,000 to 15,000 visitors a week after the free plan launched
- 07Free-to-paid conversion rate came in at 5%, beating the 3% internal model
- 08The profit-sharing pool for the second half of 2020 was set at $400K, with the average check expected to be about $5K per person
- 09Nathan Barry owned 90% of ConvertKit, with 10% in the team equity pool, of which 7% was allocated
- 10At least 3,000 affiliates were paid at least a dollar in 2020
Company Metrics at Time of Interview
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| ARR (2020) | $25M | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Monthly Revenue Run Rate (summer 2016) | $300K | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Annual Revenue Run Rate (summer 2016) | $3.6M | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Profit Margin (2020) | 5% | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Profit Margin (2016) | 50% | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Cash in Bank (2016) | $15K | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Affiliate Payouts (2020) | $250K per month | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Affiliate Commission Rate (2020) | 30% | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Paid Ads Spend (2020) | $400K per month | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Commerce GMV (since mid-July 2020 private beta) | Almost $500K | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Powered By Weekly Visitors (post-freemium launch) (2020) | 14,000 to 15,000 | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| SEO Share of New Accounts (2020) | 40% | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Free-to-Paid Conversion Rate (expected) (2020) | 3% | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Free-to-Paid Conversion Rate (actual) (2020) | 5% | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Affiliates Paid at Least $1 (2020) | At least 3,000 | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Profit Sharing Pool (H2 2020, planned) | $400K | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Average Profit Sharing Check (H2 2020, expected) | $5K | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Profit Sharing Pool (Summer 2016) | $100K | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Average Profit Sharing Check (Spring 2020) | $11K | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Smallest Profit Sharing Check (Spring 2020) | $3K | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Largest Profit Sharing Check (Spring 2020) | $19K | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Founder Equity Stake (2020) | 90% | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Team Equity Pool (2020) | 10% | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Team Equity Pool Allocated (2020) | 7% | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
| Photographer Spend per Shoot (2020) | $500 to $1,000 | Founder interview, Dec 2020 |
Growth Breakdown
Revenue
ConvertKit reached $25M ARR in 2020, up from a $3.6M annual run rate in summer 2016. The company grew from $2K MRR to $100K MRR in the twelve months before January 2016, and from $100K to $300K MRR by the time of the first team retreat in summer 2016.
Customers and Commerce
ConvertKit had 250,000 users on its platform at the time of the interview. The ConvertKit Commerce product launched in private beta in mid-July 2020 and had processed almost $500K in GMV by the time of the interview. In January 2020, the platform crossed $1 billion in total creator earnings aggregated across connected third-party platforms.
Team and Equity
The team was up to 20 people by summer 2016, six of them hired in the previous 30 days. Nathan Barry owned 90% of the equity, with 10% in a team pool, of which 7% was allocated at the time. Profit sharing was paid every six months, and the pool for the second half of 2020 was set at $400K.
Profitability and Spending
ConvertKit was still profitable late in 2020 despite spending aggressively on advertising. Its profit margin was about 5% at the time of the interview, down from close to 23% at the start of the year and from 50% in summer 2016. It was spending about $400K a month on paid ads and about $250K a month on affiliate payouts.
Growth Strategy
Powered By ConvertKit
After launching a free plan in January 2020, weekly visitors from Powered By links grew from 2,000 to 3,000 per week to 14,000 to 15,000 per week. This traffic converted much lower, perhaps 1 to 2% against 7 to 8% in other channels by Nathan Barry's own rough estimate, so it worked as a broad awareness play rather than a direct conversion channel, and it kept climbing.
Organic SEO and Creator Photo Link Building
SEO drove about 40% of all new ConvertKit accounts. A key tactic had been commissioning local photographers to shoot creator stories, releasing those photos on Unsplash as a ConvertKit creator collection, and then doing outreach to sites using the photos to request backlinks. This had generated millions of photo downloads and a large volume of inbound links.
Affiliate Marketing
Affiliates were how ConvertKit grew for a long time, at one point driving a little over 30% of all revenue. ConvertKit paid a 30% commission, about $250K a month in total, and at least 3,000 affiliates were paid at least a dollar in 2020. The channel was still growing but had been outpaced by search.
Freemium Plan Launch
ConvertKit launched a free plan in January 2020, allowing sign-ups without a credit card. The free-to-paid conversion rate came in at 5%, beating the internal model of 3%. Nathan Barry cited the Mailchimp experience as a key inspiration, noting that freemium surfaces high-value accounts that are otherwise hard to attribute to any single channel.
Direct Sales and Do Things That Don't Scale
The early inflection point in 2015 came from shifting away from content-only growth to a direct sales model: doing custom development work, personally migrating customers, and doing whatever it took to inch forward. This Paul Graham-style approach was credited with turning the business from flat to compounding growth.
Best Quotes
“Yes, we're at 25,000,000 ARR right now.”
“Yeah, we've been spending a little more aggressively this year. So we're doing about 5% profit.”
“So we're paying out about 250,000, we could figure this about 250,000 a month to affiliates and paying a 30% commission. So that's the easiest way to back into it.”
“Yeah, so it drives about 40% of all of our new accounts. ... It's from search.”
“In our models, we expected a 3% free to paid conversion rate. We came in at a 5% rate and we're like, that's fantastic.”
“Yeah, so I own 90% and the team pool is 10% of which 7% is currently allocated.”
“It'll be 400,000. Our goal was actually to lose money in the second half of the year.”
“Yeah, so we have two different numbers that we track. The first one is like the total amount earned by creators using ConvertKit as email products. In beginning of twenty nineteen or 2018, I'm trying to remember exactly when we launched new APIs so that when people are selling through ConvertKit and using Shopify or Teachable or Stripe or any these others, includes the reporting of where the revenue came from and how much you're earning and it aggregates it across all these different platforms. So you have one creator dashboard.”
What Happened Next
This interview captures ConvertKit at a specific moment in December 2020, when the company was at $25M ARR and was in the early stages of its ConvertKit Commerce product. The figures here reflect what Nathan Barry reported at that time and should be read as a historical snapshot. For current revenue, team size, and product updates, visit the live Kit (formerly ConvertKit) company profile on GetLatka.
View Kit (Formerly Convertkit)’s current profile and metricsFull Transcript
Chapters
- 0:01Introduction and Community Building
- 0:31Ghost Town Investment and In-Person Community
- 5:39ConvertKit's Early Near-Death Moment and First Team Retreat
- 8:14ConvertKit Revenue and Profitability Today
- 8:57Nathan Barry's Origin Story: Woodworking and Early Sales
- 13:13College Dropout and First $10K Contract
- 24:21ConvertKit Commerce Launch and GMV Progress
- 30:02Powered By ConvertKit as a Growth Channel
- 31:13SEO Strategy and Creator Photo Link Building
- 40:38Affiliate Program Size and Payouts
- 43:52Freemium Plan Launch and Conversion Rates
- 47:08Profit Sharing, Equity Split and Paid Advertising Spend
- 55:18Acquisitions, Investments, and Capital Leverage
Introduction and Community Building
Nathan Latka
00:01Hey guys, my guest today is Nathan Barry, you've definitely heard of ConvertKit. And hopefully you've seen some other things he's working on related to tiny houses investing in friends companies, but most importantly, just creating and building and supporting the creator ecosystem as he really brings his customers to the forefront of everything he's doing, whether it's sharing their stories on a podcast, writing about them on the blog, or many other ways they do this at ConvertKit. We're
00:26going to touch on all this today. Nathan Barry, thanks for coming on the show.
Nathan Barry
00:29>> Yeah, thanks for having me.
Ghost Town Investment and In-Person Community
Nathan Latka
00:31Okay, so the first thing I want to touch on is actually is not software related. Know, we're in a very weird time right now where everyone's sort of locked down. We also know that your community is extremely important. You've personally built community both online and in person. And I want to go back to sort of pre COVID days and just ask for your thesis on why you decided to get involved with your friend Brent in buying
00:53an old ranch and how that relates to community.
Nathan Barry
00:56>> Yeah, oh man. Well, if I look back on my journey as an entrepreneur, so many of the inflection points came from people that I met in person, right? Say a conference like MicroConf, where there was one years ago that Amy Hoy and Alex Hellman put on called Bacon Biz, which is just a fantastic conference. And it was just for the people who were focused on making money, right? And there's all of these events that you hang
01:23>> out with, hang out at and meet someone and they're the one who drops an idea that changes something for you. Or for example, there was this conference years ago called the World Domination Summit that Chris Guillebeau hosted. And I went in 2012 and I knew no one, super shy, like, okay, I guess let's do this. I'm supposed to meet people, you know, that kind of thing. And I just decided to walk up and talk to two
01:47>> guys who were standing there talking. Turns out to be James Clear, who's the author of Atomic Habits now. But like at the time he had a tiny little newsletter.
Nathan Latka
01:57Yeah, pre books.
Nathan Barry
01:58>> Yeah, well before anything. And then Caleb Wojcik, who's this incredible video producer. He's done everything for Pat Flynn. He invented the SwitchPod with Pat Flynn, all of this, right? And that's the kind of thing that happens when you show up at an event that's a curated group of people and you have these conversations in person. And so I've always just been a fan of great in person experiences. We've started our own conference four years ago, ran
02:29>> that every year except for this year. And so it's just something that I've loved. And so when actually Ryan Holiday was the one who texted me and was like, Hey, we're buying a ghost town and like it's closing soon and we need more money.
Nathan Latka
02:49Yeah. And with Brian, you gotta go wait a second. Is this a headline he's pitching? Because you know, genius, Mark or is this a real like, you actually, is there actually a ghost town or bot?
Nathan Barry
02:57>> Yes, exactly. And I had known Brett Underwood from, because he has an agency with Ryan and they run the website Daily Stoic together, which is a ConvertKit customer. And so I'd known him somewhat, but Ryan was the one that kind of pulled me in. And it was just this thing where, because it was a unique property and this is Cerro Gordo, which is a 300 acre ghost town in the Sierra Nevada Mountains. So when you stand
03:27>> on the peak behind it, if you look to one side, you see Mount Whitney. So the highest point in the Continental US. And if you turn around and look behind you, you see Death Valley, which is the lowest point. And it's just this crazy place. And so then I thought, okay, one, Brent and Ryan and their other partner, John, just have this great idea for what they're going to do with it. And I was like, can
03:52>> you imagine the mastermind groups and the like mini conferences and the writers retreats and whatever else that you can have, like the stories and memories that you can make at a place like this. And so, I had to get involved.
Nathan Latka
04:06And so what has happened? Obviously COVID changes and Brent's putting out great content on YouTube. It looks like he's been living there for a while. Have you guys been able to have sort of a mastermind where you're living in old mining cabins and waking up in the morning and seeing Mount Whitney and Death Valley?
Nathan Barry
04:21>> Yeah, some of that has happened. The property has taken a lot longer, I think, than we originally had thought to get it up and running and get it to the point where groups can stay there. So I've actually only been there. I've only been there twice and just taking my family down. So we haven't yet had a big gathering because there were things like had to get running water, had to get
04:44>> it livable again.
04:47>> And then there were some big setbacks in there. Like this summer, there was a fire caused by some really old electrical that burned down the hotel there, that it was on its one hundred and forty ninth anniversary of opening that the hotel burned down. So, I mean, it's kind of like anything in entrepreneurship where you have these great grand dreams and then it turns out it's way harder than you thought. And then just when it's really
05:13>> hard, then like there's this crazy setback of like the coolest building in the whole town getting burned down or I don't know the equivalent from like you're in my businesses would be like, when you lose that customer that you've fought so hard to get or that was that stretch thing.
Nathan Latka
05:28Can you make an analogy there? If you look at ConvertKit's history and we'll dive more into ConvertKit here, but is there an equivalent to the old 149 year old hotel burning down?
ConvertKit's Early Near-Death Moment and First Team Retreat
Nathan Barry
05:39>> I think that So our very first team retreat,
05:46>> let me set the stage. So January 2016, the previous twelve months we'd grown from 2,000 in MRR to a 100,000 in MRR. Just crazy We had no money in the bank. We were thinking, should we raise money? I think we were spending $80K a month and we had like $15K of cash in the bank, but we were making
Nathan Latka
06:04Sorry, net burn was $80K a month or gross burn?
Nathan Barry
06:09>> Gross, where we're still profitable and like the dollar amounts were going up. Like the bank balance is getting bigger,
06:19>> but at the same time,
06:23>> you know, like your days worth of expenses is going down, right? Because $15K in the bank when you have $5K of MRR and $5K of expenses, that's fine. But when you have $100K like, it's not cool anymore.
Nathan Latka
06:35Yeah. We had a $100K MRR, $80K expenses, $15K in the bank, team retreat.
Nathan Barry
06:41>> Yeah. So that's where we were. Had basically, we wanted to get the team together because we had, I don't know, thirteen, fourteen people on the team at the time. And we thought, okay, but we just can't afford it. And so we cut expenses, doubled down, or we didn't cut expenses. We basically locked expenses and then grew our way out of it. And we grew our way from like barely break even to five months later, we had
07:06>> 60%, sorry, 50% profit margins, three months of expenses in the bank. And we did a team retreat to celebrate. And so that was like the big high in entrepreneurship. And the whole team flies into Boise. We have like, everyone's showing up for this team retreat and we get a denial of service attack where someone goes like very deliberate, very malicious goes to take down our servers. And, you know, it's like, I distinctly remember picking up Brad,
07:32>> one of our lead engineers at the airport and I show up and he's like next to baggage claim on his laptop, like trying to keep the servers up. And it's that sort of thing where you go from these crazy high and it's like, Oh man, I can't believe we pulled that off. To the equivalent of your hotel burning down or like this, like, I don't know how we're gonna recover from this. And you always do. That's
07:54>> just part of entrepreneurship, but that's the journey that we all signed up for.
Nathan Latka
07:59Nathan, I want people to stick around. And so I want you to plant a big open loop here. And then we're gonna dive more into the sort of emotional side of the story going back to when you were doing woodwork at 13 years old, door knocking. Today, where's ConvertKit? What's top line revenue?
ConvertKit Revenue and Profitability Today
Nathan Barry
08:14>> Yes, we're at 25,000,000 ARR right now.
Nathan Latka
08:17And how much profit?
Nathan Barry
08:19>> Yeah, we've been spending a little more aggressively this year. So we're doing about 5% profit.
08:27>> But at the beginning of the year, we're close to 23%. So next year we'll return to the 20% mark.
Nathan Latka
08:3520% EBITDA margin? Yeah. So guys, you wanna stick around for that? Something else Nathan is doing, which he puts on his website as he specifically says $1,800,000 paid out to the team. So there's some profit sharing happening here. A lot of you guys who are bootstrap founders are wondering how the heck do I set up profit sharing without spending $500,000 on legal. So we'll get back to that in a second. Nathan, take us back to 2013.
Nathan Barry's Origin Story: Woodworking and Early Sales
Nathan Latka
08:57Sorry, when you were 13. Nathan, I think what maybe 2005 or earlier.
Nathan Barry
09:01>> 2003.
Nathan Latka
09:022003. '90. '19. Okay. Wow. '19. Okay. So we're about the same year. What? '30 right now?
Nathan Barry
09:07>> Yep. '30.
Nathan Latka
09:08Okay. So woodworking. So first off, do you remember the moment did your Was there something you really wanted and you needed to make money and your parents said you gotta figure out a way to make money and then you said, I'm gonna go sell woodworking or what was the genesis of that first thing you created?
Nathan Barry
09:23>> Yeah, well, for me, like I grew up in a household where money was really scarce. My dad ran like a Christian college ministry. And so it lived off of donations and support from churches or other groups. And so money was just not a thing that there was much of. And so my parents did a really good job of instilling that like, if you want money, go earn it. And the way that I did it was my
09:50>> dad was really into woodworking. He built the house that we grew up in. So we had this like little shop of, it was a lot of like kind of hand me down tools, but it worked great. And so I would do these woodworking projects and then go door to door to sell them to earn money. And I remember I had made a bunch of these like wood carvings and stuff. And we were headed in, it was
10:14>> actually Black Friday. So we're gonna head into town because we grew up in the mountains outside of town. We could do some Black Friday shopping.
Nathan Latka
10:22Hey, Nathan, which town I know obviously, but I don't know the audience.
Nathan Barry
10:24>> Yeah, Boise, Idaho. Yep.
10:28>> And so
10:31>> we were going to do that. It was one of those things we're going to head into town at noon or something like that. And so at 10AM, I was like, great, I'm gonna go wander around this neighborhood, go door to door, and then like, pick me up here, you know, a mile from town, and then we'll just see how much money I've made by that. Wow. It was one of those things where I think I made
10:51>> $100 $120 selling these things door to door an hour later when my parents picked me up as we drove into town. And that was just sort of the mindset that we always had of like, great, if you want something, I'm not gonna give it to you. Go pursue it. Go figure out how to get it done.
Nathan Latka
11:09What their reaction when you got in the car and emptied your pockets with a bunch of crumpled up dollar bills?
Nathan Barry
11:17>> What's funny is I think they were so used to us just as kids figuring out how to make money that they were just like, cool. And there wasn't like, it wasn't even this big celebration moment. Was just like, well, yeah, obviously.
Nathan Latka
11:31Who's us Nathan? How many siblings?
Nathan Barry
11:33>> I have five siblings. I have fourth of six kids.
Nathan Latka
11:38Okay, okay. Wow, fourth of six. That's incredible. Okay. And are they so so did they all end up just building sort of communities and creators world or or did did one of them end up in like Wall Street finance or something?
Nathan Barry
11:51>> I do have a brother who works in corporate finance buys I private
11:58>> mean, everyone's all over the map. I've got a sister that lives in Seattle and works on copywriting and that kind of thing for a bunch of big clients like eBay and American Airlines, or sorry, Alaska Airlines. Yeah, brother who's a physician's assistant, got a couple of siblings who are programmers. You know, it's just, it's all over the map. And I think that's, you get into a whole nature versus nurture sort of debate, but I think, humans
12:23>> are just very different.
Nathan Latka
12:24Now, Nathan, has your little guy had his woodworking door to door knocking first sales moment?
Nathan Barry
12:30>> I don't know. Let me think about this. We don't do an allowance or anything, so they come to us with ways to earn money. I think this year probably would have been the year of the lemonade stand or something like that. Just based on my kids are nine, six, and then 11. And, it's just, it's not a With COVID, it's not a good year for door to door sales.
Nathan Latka
12:57Yeah. Definitely not a good thing. Opposite of what you wanna be doing. Yeah. Okay. So wow, $120 woodworking, four of six siblings, 2005, you're 13 years old. You eventually obviously end up, I believe going to college. Let's fast forward here a bit. What did you do in college? What did you study?
College Dropout and First $10K Contract
Nathan Barry
13:13>> Yeah, I studied graphic design and then marketing. So I wanted to do graphic design, Photoshop interface design and all of that. And I went to college super early because all my friends were older than me. I was homeschooled and I wanted to keep up with them. And so I basically asked my Hey, is high school four years or is high school a set amount of work? And to their credit, they said like, Oh, it's a set
13:42>> amount of work. And I was like, Great. Can I have that in to do list form? Cause basically all my friends were gonna graduate two years before I was and go off to college and I didn't wanna be left behind. And so when my parents listed all out and I had older siblings who had finished high school already, and so they had already figured out this will be all the homeschooling curriculum. Then I just sat down
14:03>> and knocked it out. I remember thinking, I'm bored when we go on these family road trips from Boise to Seattle every summer. I'm also bored when I do algebra. So why don't I combine these things? And on like an eight hour drive, I do a month's worth of algebra lessons or something. And so then I graduated high school when I was 15 and started going to college.
Nathan Latka
14:25And graduated college how old?
Nathan Barry
14:27>> I dropped out of college at 17.
Nathan Latka
14:29Okay. Okay. So why the dropout? Were you making just so much money selling your own stuff at that point or why drop out?
Nathan Barry
14:36>> Yeah. So I was going to college to learn how to make money. This was all a quest of, I want to figure out how I can make money
14:45>> earn a living and eventually become financially independent. And I had started a web design business by then. It was doing well. Basically, I got my first $10,000 contract and I called my mom and said, Hey, I think I'm ready to drop out of college. And I expected to have to convince her that it was a good idea. And she'd followed my progress and I talked to her about the web design business I'd been running and the
15:11>> freelancing and stuff like And she just said like, Yeah, I expected that we'd have this conversation soon. So, yeah, my Did clinched name
Nathan Latka
15:19she have money on the line? Were your parents helping cover college expenses or anything like that? Or were you paying yourself?
Nathan Barry
15:25>> I was paying for it myself. I got a lot of grants because the low income FAFSA grants and stuff like that, financial aid. And then the rest So I dropped out with $5,000 of student loans rather than a crazy amount. So yeah, that was a case where coming from a low income family really helped.
Nathan Latka
15:47You, and we're gonna, I wanna put all this sort of on a mental map which you've used and I can't credit the person because I forget maybe you can the ladders of wealth who created that again?
Nathan Barry
15:58>> That's just an idea that I've dreamed.
Nathan Latka
16:01That was you. Okay, I wasn't sure if you pulled that out of a book or if that was you. Okay, got it. So Nathan has put together sort of ladders of wealth that explains how he thinks about wealth creation and so one of the things you talked about is sort of moving from trading your time to eventually, you know, bundling your hours into project sort of things, would you call this 10 ks sale your, your first
16:19sort of bundled agency product where you weren't selling hours?
Nathan Barry
16:24>> Yeah, and I think that one I was still, that was probably this transition, right? Between selling hours and like selling an outcome.
16:34>> And so, yeah, that was an early example of a product, but still largely hourly project based work. But it was definitely on a continuum. It was not the hourly web design work that I've been doing before. It was like, okay, now I'm getting paid for an outcome. And there's starting to be this disconnect between the effort that I put in and the money that I make, which is what we're looking for in entrepreneurship, right? As these
17:00>> things are tightly coupled, there's no leverage, But the more those can be disconnected, then there's at least an opportunity for leverage. It can go terribly wrong and you can have a project that like you're a hundred hours in to deliver this outcome that you're not getting paid enough for, then the leverage goes poorly. But we try to create those situations where the leverage goes well, where we can deliver a ton of value with less inputs and
17:25>> get paid for it.
Nathan Latka
17:26Nathan, one of your recent tweets was something along the lines of, is there anything that you've actually committed to and done consistently for a long period of time and not had success? And there were a couple replies, but I mean, if I didn't know you personally and I just looked at charts and graphs and numbers, I would sum it up by saying consistency, but both maybe people would say sometimes bad consistency and good consistency. And so
17:48like bad consistency, which it's not actually bad, but when you look between 2013 and 2015, you were so consistent at ConvertKit. MRR never really got above five k per month. It was sort of one to five k. And then in 2015, something happens. And literally the curve of your revenue growth shifted. And now it's been like literally consistent for five years in terms of just growth. There's very little like blips happening. Is this intentional?
Nathan Barry
18:15>> Well, I think it's that all of these things take a lot more time. And so we think about if I show up in the right way, then I'll achieve the success or something. And that's true. It often takes a long time to figure out how to show up and what things to work on. And so I can ConvertKit things that made a difference were moving from like content driven, you know, for trying to grow a SaaS
18:42>> business. Content by the way is a really hard way to grow a business. Like go from zero to one and like basic, like no traction to simple traction. And that's what I was trying to do. But if you don't have the community already, it's very hard to do. And it was really shifting from that to a direct sales model of kind of this Paul Graham, like do things that don't scale, do anything to get the customer,
19:05>> do custom development work, migrate them all yourself, all that and do these things to inch forward the progress. And that's what turned into something that was actually working. And then,
19:18>> Naval Ravikan talks a lot about looking for things in life that compound and so much in entrepreneurship compounds just like it does in investing and everything else where those returns come over time and they come much later. And if you remember learning about compound interest in middle school, you're like, wait, this isn't actually any good. You're saying that I'm going to put in all of this and then five years later, this is what I get from
19:47>> it? And it's just not impressive at all. And then you have to fast forward another ten years, another twenty years. And you're like, this is incredible. This is mind blowing. How does it turn into that? And it's like, well, compounding takes time. And I think in entrepreneurship, we're like that kid in middle school where we're like five years and that's all I get. Like no point. And we fail to look further down the road and be
20:08>> like, Oh, but in ten years it'll be this. And that's what I think everyone does with their companies where say a company like Mailchimp. I don't have their exact numbers. I'm assuming at this point based on trends from previous numbers, there's somewhere around $750,000,000 in annual revenue. Maybe as much as a billion, but probably not quite there yet.
20:30>> They've been at it for nineteen years. And so when I look at the curve that I'm on with ConvertKit and the curve that Mailchimp did, and if we were to overlay those two, ConvertKit is far ahead. If we put the start date of the two of them, ConvertKit is far ahead on that curve than Mailchimp was eight years into their business. And I think this is the point where people go like, wow, you've made it with
20:55>> ConvertKit. You should sell. You should have sold a while Like the moment that first $100,000,000 acquisition offer came up, you should have sold and move on to the next thing.
Nathan Latka
21:03When was that?
Nathan Barry
21:05>> So we haven't had like a crisp, like here's the offer on the table, but like the private equity people show up nonstop.
Nathan Latka
21:13And
Nathan Barry
21:15>> I just always say no thanks before it gets to
Nathan Latka
21:18Just charge for the call. Say, I'll get on a call with you, but it's $5,000 for twenty minutes. And then make a That's little a good idea.
Nathan Barry
21:28>> And anyway, so I guess what I'm saying is I feel like I'm just getting started. And if I want to build the scale of company that I need to, or that I want to do, then I need to give compounding time to really kick in. So we're eight years in and selling and being done now is just way too early. And so it's really like, if I want to build a Mailchimp level company or a Stripe
21:52>> level company or something like that, then it's like, great, show up for another decade. And then we can start to talk about the level of commitment that you have and where the results come from.
Nathan Latka
22:00I mean, Nathan, is it really sort of a start and a stop? I mean, everything I'm seeing you do. I mean, this is this is just you. It's build a creator community. It's build team members. It's allow your team members to build wealth with profit sharing. You're obviously also making money. You're then reinvesting in friends businesses and things you love and and you're talking about you know now not only multiplying your time or an agency work
22:24or now software, but also now capital leverage after that. I mean, what would you do if you sold ConvertKit?
Nathan Barry
22:31>> I don't even know. Maybe build a tiny house community But you're already doing that. Yeah. And that's the thing of like, it's not this all or nothing. I think that's a really good question to ask when those acquisition offers come in or something like, okay, but what would I do? And I go right back to building software because I love it. And one thing that I love now is the leverage that we have. So for example,
23:00>> this year we launched ConvertKit commerce, which is our digital product sales platform. And if I were to That's something that's just different enough from ConvertKit that it could be its own startup entirely. And so if I were to start over and do that, that initial traction is really hard to get. It's lot of work. Obviously having done a successful company, the next one is easier, the relationships that you already have, the brand reputation and everything. But
23:26>> now for ConvertKit, like, Oh, we have 250,000 users and so let's just tell them to use this new thing. And so when you come out with something, you're like, Wow, this is getting used by thousands and thousands of people, which is the creator's dream. And so it's one of those things that if you sell it, if you move on, then you lose that or some amount of that leverage. So I'm just like, nope, I like the
23:47>> leverage too much. I'm going to keep doing this.
Nathan Latka
23:49It's great. And it's so hard to quantify like this leverage idea is so hard to quantify. So it's I wanna dig here a little bit. Let me just ask a bit, obviously commerce and any, we call it sort of a SaaS plus plays a SaaS business plus something else, professional services, percent of GMV model, a marketplace maybe. When you look at the commerce business, one of the goals you talk about is, man, love to get to
24:11the the point where we pay a billion dollars or help creators make a billion dollars. You launched last year in 2019. How much went through your system in 2020 to creators?
ConvertKit Commerce Launch and GMV Progress
Nathan Barry
24:21>> Yeah, so we have two different numbers that we track. The first one is like the total amount earned by creators using ConvertKit as email products. In beginning of twenty nineteen or 2018, I'm trying to remember exactly when we launched new APIs so that when people are selling through ConvertKit and using Shopify or Teachable or Stripe or any these others, includes the reporting of where the revenue came from and how much you're earning and it aggregates it
24:50>> across all these different platforms. So you have one creator dashboard. And that's been really cool. And actually January of this year, passed a billion dollars earned by creators on ConvertKit
Nathan Latka
25:02or through
Nathan Barry
25:05>> like other platforms.
25:05>> Through the aggregation.
Nathan Latka
25:06Yeah. Through the aggregation.
Nathan Barry
25:07>> Yeah.
25:08>> And so now with ConvertKit commerce, it's basically like, we checked out this big goal, which is on our mission page. And then we said like, done, next, now it has to be a billion, like processed through our payment systems.
25:24>> And that we launched in private beta in mid July. And one thing that's been interesting is it is much harder to get traction than I expected. So we're at almost half a million in GMV
25:39>> and it's fascinating how
Nathan Latka
25:41It's total GMV process through July.
Nathan Barry
25:44>> Yeah. And so it's a lot lower. Just for example, the conversation that we were having over email, you're like, Hey, have you hit that billion dollars yet? And I was like, Not only have I not hit it, but this is hard. And it's again, these compound returns that are going to come into play. You've got to get people to switch over from what they're doing. You've got to get all the beginners who are thinking about selling
26:05>> their first product, right? They made their first $50 their first $100 and it's going to be a few years before they're making 10,000, 100,000. And so it's been a really healthy reminder for me of, oh yeah, I'm starting compounding on a new thing and it's going to take time because I'm that entrepreneur who's like, okay, let's Let's be at a million by this date and then a million a month by that day. And then, you know,
26:33>> and just realizing like to get all of this momentum to shift, it takes a lot of time. And so I'm having to learn both to put in the concerted effort and to be patient for the results.
Nathan Latka
26:43And how do you think about launching new product like that? Do you really go deep on a persona and maybe actually use that persona? You call Pat Flynn say, Pat, I know you do more than 1,000,000 a year in revenue. We'd love to process all your commerce. What's that have to look like for you to switch over? Or do you try and build something more broad and appeal to a 100 beta users? I think you try
27:01to do both because
Nathan Barry
27:05>> you can fall into traps in both ways. And like we use we use OKRs, objectives and key results, to manage and track our business. And what you usually end up doing is having a main objective that you're going after. And in our case, like let's say GMV, right? We're trying to We want the most dollars sold. But if you optimize only for that metric, then you might do things that is for short term gain, but not
27:32>> the long term. We could say, okay, we're trying to get to 10,000,000 in GMV in X amount of time. Then if I just go out and get a single client that sells a million dollars a month, done. We're set. But that isn't success for the platform. And so then could go the other extreme and say like, Oh, I'm going to help X number of creators earn their first dollar. And that's all well and good, but everybody
27:59>> follows the big names. So if you don't have any of the big names, it's way harder to get those. And so what I look for is the key metric, which is GMV and then the counterbalancing metric. And so in this case, we're looking to drive the most GMV. That's the main thing. Small creators, big creators all contribute to that, but obviously the big creators drive far more. And then I have a counterbalancing metric of I want
28:21>> X number of creators to have earned at least a dollar on the platform. So that says, I'm going after this big number, but I also have to include all the small creators because two years from now, three years from now, they are the big creators. So that way I'm not trading short term success for long
28:42>> term results. Because five years from now, I get tens of thousands of the small creators, then I'm for sure going to have, like there'll be the big creators five years from now.
Nathan Latka
28:54It reminds me, you think politics, and I know you dabbled on the hill for a bit. It's sort of like when the folks report their fundraising numbers and its average check size. You want millions of small donors versus one massive donor if you're gonna build a movement.
Nathan Barry
29:08>> Yep, for sure.
Nathan Latka
29:09Okay, so that's the status of convert commerce. Let me give a little bit of ammo here to our SaaS folks that are listening and going, I want tactics. Nathan is amazing. From what I can tell, you've used really three acquisition channels really effectively. One sort of the powered by ConvertKit. In fact, in one of your Twitter tweets, you said, hey, why did you upgrade? And there were folks when we wanted to pay to remove the powered
29:32by ConvertKit. So you get obviously some free clicks and a lot of free traffic from that. I think you also have a great affiliate program. I noticed the affiliate link in your guys' footer and you also have big names that are known for promoting products they really believe in. And then lastly, your SEO content seems to be super strong. You put some of the key anchor articles in your footer as well. So I'd love to spend
29:53five minutes just touching on those. Could we maybe start with like the powered by ConvertKit? Can you quantify the success you've had using that as a growth channel?
Powered By ConvertKit as a Growth Channel
Nathan Barry
30:02>> Yeah, so it's still relatively early. Just for some more context, we've always been a paid product, like free trial but you gotta pay to use it until January of this year when we launched And
30:15>> so you can see like prior to this year, so last year maybe we were driving two to 3,000 visitors a week through Powered by links. And then after launching freemium, scaling that up, we're now driving fourteen, fifteen thousand visitors a week from Powered by links. So you're just seeing, and it's actually a couple of step functions in there as we made our free plan more valuable, got the adoption up, stuff like that. Now Powered by traffic
30:43>> converts a lot lower than other traffic. I don't have the exact numbers in front of me, you know, if a visitor to visitor to free account conversion rate is seven or 8%, like in other channels, then Powered by traffic might convert at one to 2%. So it's much more of this like broad awareness play than like a direct conversion, but just like not many traffic channels just keep climbing like that. So it's really fun to see.
SEO Strategy and Creator Photo Link Building
Nathan Barry
31:13>> The next one, search is really like just that anchor that we've, I don't know, gradually invested in over time. And now it pays off in a big way.
31:28>> Actually In a massive way.
Nathan Latka
31:30I mean, if you look at Ahrefs, I mean, you're now generating almost 70,000 organic keywords. You're getting a 120,000 clicks organically per month. I think that's unique. 10,200,000 backlinks. So there's obviously a credit to probably a bunch of hosted page products that you guys have, but I mean, you're killing it in SEO.
Nathan Barry
31:45>> Yeah. So it drives about 40% of all of our new accounts. Wow. It's from search. One interesting, if people are looking for like a quick tip for link building, that's been fascinating. We didn't do it on purpose, but it's worked out really well. Is we've been doing these creator stories where we profile creators, tell their story, and we've been paying for photographers to come out, and like a local photographer to come, do all the photos for
32:13>> the story and give it to the creator and say, Hey, use these on your website, use these. Because if you've ever built a website for yourself, you're like realizing, Oh, and here's where I'll put the perfect header. And you realize like, I don't have that. I haven't hired a And photographer to do so people love it, right, when we give those away. But then what we also did is say, hey, we have this Unsplash
32:34>> collection of creator photos. If you'd like, we'll release those. If you sign off on it and you're up for it, we'll release those photos on Unsplash as part of our ConvertKit creator collection.
32:48>> That has like, there's millions and millions of downloads of those photos now. And a bunch of people will credit ConvertKit. But what's interesting is on all the popular sites that use them and they get used a lot, we just send a quick little outreach email and say, Hey, I saw that you used this photo. I'd love it if you provided a backlink back to, you know, if you linked back to ConvertKit as the creator of this
33:13>> photo, if not, no worries, it's like license and a creative comm, you don't have to, but if you want to, we'd love it. And that has driven so many backlinks because you get these photos that millions of people are using And they're just like, Oh yeah, sure, I'd love to give credit. And especially when you're upfront of like, You don't need to at all. We're not coming and saying, You have to do this.
Nathan Latka
33:34Fascinating. How much did you spend on local photographers featuring your customers in 2020? Do you have a general idea?
Nathan Barry
33:41>> That's a good question. I don't have that. I'd say 500 to $1,000 per shoot somewhere in there and then maybe one shoot per week.
Nathan Latka
33:52Okay, got it. So this tactic could cost 50 to $100,000 per year.
Nathan Barry
33:57>> Yeah, exactly.
Nathan Latka
33:59And you get direct return in the form of these backlinks, but you also get just amazing community return. I mean, this helps your customers in so many ways and it's free.
Nathan Barry
34:08>> Yeah, so this is kind of the way that I think about marketing is if there's an activity that we're going to do, we're going to release these creator stories because we wanna be a brand known for great storytelling. I think all the most iconic brands storytellers. And so we're like, great, okay, let's start telling stories. And then we need a process for that. So there's like, we need to do photos for the stories, we need to
34:33>> do other things. And you end up with this sequence of events that do, and you do this over and over again. And I think that's the way that most people approach marketing or whatever task of like, I have to do A, B and C, and I will do that a bunch of times. And
34:49>> now, I guess it's Jim Collins in Good to Great talks about flywheels and taking all of these sequences of events and turning them into a flywheel where each step logically feeds into the next and around and around you go. And so we think about it in marketing of these different stories. We want to produce a great story and it needs writing and photography and around there. And since we're producing the photography, we should promote that and
35:16>> share it as many places as So that's where these Unsplash collections come in, because then that will get more attention for the stories. And then our SEO flywheel should fit into that of like, Oh, since this asset is being created and millions of people are downloading it, let's tie that into our link outreach and basically see how can I make these different systems that when they fit together, every rotation of the flywheel makes the next rotation
35:42>> easier? And I look for that everywhere of, okay, great. If we're doing this one activity here, how can it serve the rest of the business? Or how can it have these other byproducts that are really valuable?
Nathan Latka
35:55Nathan, is there somebody on your team that you've hired that is solely responsible for watching systems that other people are running, documenting the system and then creating the flywheel? Or do you try and build that into the DNA where everyone, if they do something that works, have to document it and share it so you can invest in systematizing?
Nathan Barry
36:12>> Yeah, I would say there's not one person. The person who does it the most is Barrett Brooks, who's our COO. And he's been with the team for quite a while. He started working in marketing and then grew to leading marketing and then is now COO. So he's probably the best advocate, but it's definitely something that we're trying to teach everyone to do. Like Issa Adney, runs, her title is Storyteller. She's the person who we taught this
36:42>> to at a high level, in the company. And she's just like, Okay, I'm going to take that concept and run with it and take it so much further than you thought. And so she's the one that's implemented all of that. And to give you an idea of where it's at now,
36:56>> I'm working on a book called Create Every Day. And so in writing those chapters, I'll get stuck and I'll be like, okay, I need, what do I need? I need a story of a creator who created really consistently every day, you know? And so I'll be like, Issa, what do have there? And she goes to her database of all the creators that she's interviewed and says, Here's four of them. I'm like, Oh, perfect. I dive into
37:16>> the stories, there's already great photography, there's already these quotes and everything. And then I'll come back a while later and be like, Okay, I need someone who really persisted for a long time and didn't get the success early. They got it three years, four years in. And she goes to her database and she's like, oh, here's these four people. And so obviously we're doing the work to tell the stories, to build the brand that we want,
37:40>> but we're trying to do it in a way that serves everybody else. So then when our content team is writing something about how to use commerce or a new, like how to do email marketing or growing a list. Like they're pulling these snippets and examples from the rest of the content machine basically.
Nathan Latka
38:00This is fascinating to hear how you build all these on top of each other.
38:07You've now stacked a bunch of these things and one of the things that I'm curious to ask you is you clearly focus on community. I mean you must at some point see yourself almost like a talent agency for creators where you're making them their own celebrity with the photos with the distribution and there then that enables them to get attention and build their own brands. You ever think about that? Are we gonna see a ConvertKit talent
38:30agency for creators?
Nathan Barry
38:32>> I don't think we're gonna see that to quite the same extent of like us trying to get bookings and things like that. You're definitely gonna see it down the road from a marketplace perspective of here are featured products to buy and here's the best ebooks, the best photography resources, all of those sort of things as we're driving the-
Nathan Latka
38:58When does that launch? When's the ConvertKit marketplace launch?
Nathan Barry
39:01>> It's probably a couple of years off.
Nathan Latka
39:03Okay.
Nathan Barry
39:04>> Just for like a little bit of,
39:07>> I don't know if it's inside baseball or what, but marketplaces are a very trendy, exciting thing to do. And one thing, we almost went from what we have today right into, and then let's do a marketplace. And what we realized is when it comes to discovery
39:27>> using the attention of the platform that we have for more creators to be discovered, there's a lot that we could do of making each piece of content created in ConvertKit available to be discovered on other platforms. So if you think about internal discovery versus external discovery, internal is like, oh, you just finished reading this article, or because you're subscribed to James Clear, you should also subscribe to Jim Ferriss, that kind of thing. And that's what Medium
39:52>> has done a lot of and that sort of thing. But what we realized is the step we need to do first is the external discovery of the little things of like, oh, I just subscribed to Nathan's list and it pops up and says like, hey, you should tweet about it. And we put these little moments all the way through. So every time you buy a product, every time you subscribe to a list, these little viral loops
40:17>> happen for the creator. And basically we'd be getting ahead of ourselves if we're like, Oh, let's do it on our platform, When really we're trying to say like, No, let's get it out there onto Let's automatically post to Twitter on behalf of the creators. Automatically So do these other it's basically external discovery first and then later do the internal once the platform is bigger.
Affiliate Program Size and Payouts
Nathan Latka
40:38Before we move on to profit sharing and how you build a great team and keep great humans around you building ConvertKit, touch on affiliates real quick. How much revenue did you pay out to affiliates in 2020?
Nathan Barry
40:49>> I don't have that number off the top of my head.
40:53>> Affiliates has been a huge channel for us and it's been declining. Let's see, affiliates is growing. I would just say that other channels have been growing faster. So affiliates are how we grew substantially for a long time. And at one point, affiliates were driving a little over 30% of all of our revenue. That's probably dropped into the 20% range as like the, so if we talk about flywheels or compounding, you know, these things, affiliates kicked off
41:24>> a lot faster. And then now you like, over time you get search coming in lower or like more slowly, but then search turns into this monster. Yeah, exactly. And so it's like affiliates are still growing. It's just that search is now outpacing it as far as the growth. So yeah, affiliates have been absolutely massive and it's just that a lot of it is the type of business that we're in, right? We're selling to traditional businesses, like,
41:52>> we had an affiliate program, then at your chamber of commerce event, that's not a thing anymore. But you'd be like, oh, look, I'm using ConvertKit. You tell like three of your friends, But in the community that we're in, right, a blogger uses us and loves us and tells 10,000 of their closest friends like use ConvertKit.
Nathan Latka
42:10Do you know how many affiliates you paid at least a dollar out to in 2020?
Nathan Barry
42:14>> Yeah, it'd be at least 3,000.
Nathan Latka
42:16Oh wow. Okay. Sometimes you hear a lot of concentration in these programs. That doesn't sound like huge concentration.
Nathan Barry
42:23>> Yeah. And the concentration is definitely there. And so there's probably only a 100 that are making at least $10,000 a month. But there's some in there that are making 25,000 a month or more.
42:39>> So yeah, it's a really, really solid
Nathan Latka
42:43So just to make sure I understand that Nathan. So if you've got at least a 100 affiliates making 10 a month and some making way more, I mean, that's a million.
Nathan Barry
42:49>> Yeah, it's probably too high of numbers. I'd have to dig in more.
Nathan Latka
42:53Okay, okay. I was going, wait a second. There's no way that 60% of his cost base is affiliate expenses.
Nathan Barry
42:58>> Yeah, no, that's too high. So I'd have to dig in because it might only be 20 or so.
Nathan Latka
43:04Okay, but there is some concentration at that. What you're saying is there is some concentration at the top.
Nathan Barry
43:07>> Yeah, so we're paying out about 250,000, we could figure this about 250,000 a month to affiliates and paying a 30% commission. So that's the easiest way to back into it.
Nathan Latka
43:18That's great, yeah, that's great. Yeah, so 250,000 affiliates, we can do an average into the 3,000, but it's clear there's some concentration with some driving $25K a month in the affiliate payouts.
Nathan Barry
43:27>> Yeah, so if we're dividing that out, at about 830,000 in monthly like top line revenue driven by affiliates.
Nathan Latka
43:35Yeah, that's so, okay, that's a really valuable number. Thanks for sharing that. So are these, before we move on to how you've structured profit sharing, are there any other flywheels that like you just found it and you love it, you haven't run a blog post on it yet, you haven't put on a podcast, you probably don't want to share it, but I'm going to pressure you. Anything you guys should ask about?
Freemium Plan Launch and Conversion Rates
Nathan Barry
43:52>> I think our free plan, you know, in the HR software community,
43:58>> everyone's very averse to free. They're like, No, I charge for a product. I sell things, and we get paid for the value that we provide. We're not those Silicon Valley startups that don't have a business model, or are losing money on every customer. And there's truth to both sides of it, but I just read Well, so two things. In 2018, I sat down with Ben Chestnut, the CEO of Mailchimp, at the Inc. 5000 conference. He
44:25>> was super generous with his time. We just got to chat for thirty minutes in a hotel lobby. And he was just like, Look, free was huge for us. That is the inflection point. And it still is huge. And it's not a bunch of low value customers. It is those, but it's all of these high value customers that just show up. And you're like, Where did this 100,000 subscriber account come from? You're like trying to attribute it,
44:49>> and you're like, you know, you can't figure out, like, it's not from paid, it's not from search, you know, it just doesn't make sense. And so you do customer interviews, and your product managers sit down with this account, you find out that this marketer used the free version of Mailchimp, spun up a free account, did some stuff, learned how to use the product, grew it to, I don't know, 50 subscribers, 500 subscribers, something that's not material
45:11>> for Mailchimp, and then got a job at this big company who was using Constant Contact. And he's like, No, I'm not using Constant Contact for this. Let me go use Mailchimp, which is the tool that I know how to use. And so basically, freemium drove all of this where they would get big accounts switching over, knowing how to use the tool right away. He was just like, this is mind blowing, this is amazing. And we were
45:37>> in the process of figuring out how could we offer a free plan. We basically looked at it and said, look, what if as a profitable company with plenty of cash in the bank and all of that, we started to adopt some of these more like Silicon Valley startup methodologies and said, we don't have to make money from every customer upfront. We can play this long game because we're profitable.
45:59>> And so we launched that free plan and honestly, it's doing so well. In our models, we expected a 3% free to paid conversion rate. We came in at a 5% rate and we're like, that's fantastic.
Nathan Latka
46:18>> And just
46:18to be clear, Nathan, sorry, that's Do you require a credit card when they sign up for free trial?
Nathan Barry
46:25>> So you can sign up for a free account without a credit card.
Nathan Latka
46:31And
Nathan Barry
46:32>> then if you wanna try out our automations product or something like that, you can start a free trial for the paid version. And that requires a credit card to go from the free version to trialing that on a fourteen day trial.
Nathan Latka
46:44And then you're saying you expected 3% conversion and it got five?
Nathan Barry
46:49>> Yeah. 3%. So not 3% conversion on the trial but 3% of all free accounts converting to a paid account. Wow. It ended up at five and we see a lot of opportunity to bump that a little higher, maybe to six or 7%.
Profit Sharing, Equity Split and Paid Advertising Spend
Nathan Latka
47:08Let's about, let's wrap up with two topics here. One is keeping great people around you, right? You're not venture backed. So you can't just go pay people 3,000,000 a year to stick with you. And that's not a race that you wanna be in anyway. When did you launch profit sharing and how does it work?
Nathan Barry
47:23>> Yeah, so we have iterated with a lot of different profit sharing things. We launched profit sharing on our very first Team Retreat. As we talked about earlier
Nathan Latka
47:33What year was that Nathan? Sorry, 2016?
Nathan Barry
47:35>> Yeah, summer twenty sixteen.
Nathan Latka
47:37Okay.
Nathan Barry
47:40>> And we had grown from 100 ks to 300 ks in monthly revenue. We'd saved up three months of expenses in the bank. We'd gotten to 50% profit margins through like the team being really lean. And I wanted to reward the team for it. So we took $100K and paid it out to the team in profit sharing. Everyone was totally blown away.
Nathan Latka
47:59How'd you do that though? How many were on the team at that point? 12?
Nathan Barry
48:03>> We were up to 20, but six of them had been hired in the previous thirty days.
Nathan Latka
48:09Okay, so 14 participated?
Nathan Barry
48:12>> Yeah, everyone participated, but for some people it was like $600.
Nathan Latka
48:15So that's my question is if someone right now is managing twenty twenty with 100 ks and they want to do this exact same thing, how do you decide who to give the check size to? Is there a formula?
Nathan Barry
48:27>> Yeah, so what we do is we do a six month period, is when the profit sharing is. And so for everyone that has been there for the entire period, you're eligible for it. And we actually give partial credit. So we give out, like if you joined, we have people who will join and then like profit sharing is thirty days later. And they're like, you still get $500.
Nathan Latka
48:49That's amazing.
Nathan Barry
48:50>> Because we want them to kind of have that taste of it. Yes. And the person next to you got 17,000 or something. But that's because they've been with the company for quite a while. So in that pool,
49:01>> it is 75% based on you're just a team member and everybody participates equally. Then 25% is based on time with the company. We take, there's just a spreadsheet that has everyone's start date. Like, so all the team members, their start date, how many days since that, and it totals up, you know, the total days worked, like ever. And then it distributes, you know, so it just says X percentage of this pool should go to Charlie because
49:32>> she's been with us for four years to, you know, this person because they've been with us for one year.
Nathan Latka
49:37Interesting.
Nathan Barry
49:38>> So like the profit sharing that we did
49:42>> in the spring, let me think, the average was $11,000 per person. The smallest check was $3,000 for someone who joined really recently. And the biggest was, I think 19,000. And so that's kind of the swing that you'll get. We used to have something in there where we had another score for individual performance and we took that out and we basically decided we're going to set a high bar for performance, just like to work at this company.
50:13>> Default. And then everyone wins and loses together.
Nathan Latka
50:16Fascinating. Okay, and you're paying this out, you're doing this calculation once a month or once every six months?
Nathan Barry
50:21>> Every six months.
Nathan Latka
50:22Okay, got it. Interesting. Okay, and so you're gonna be doing this sometime soon in the next thirty days as you close out 2020, what's the total pool that you'll be paying out?
Nathan Barry
50:35>> It'll be 400,000. Our goal was actually to lose money in the second half of the year.
Nathan Latka
50:41And now you sound like a TechCrunch, thirsty headline chaser VC guy.
Nathan Barry
50:45>> Exactly. Our goal is to lose money.
Nathan Latka
50:49We
Nathan Barry
50:50>> have not spent much on advertising as a company. Year we're like, okay, we're going to double down and we're going to spend aggressively on, you know, brand and product advertising. And we didn't do that. We spent a bunch in the first half of the year, but we were still way more profitable than we expected. We doubled down further in the second half of the year and our accounting team last week was like, guys, we're still profitable.
51:15>> So
51:19>> it's going to be smaller. I think the average check size is going be $5K instead of like the $11K that it was last time, but
Nathan Latka
51:25Do you hear any pushback from teammates when they sort of have already calculated what they think their check's going to be? And then you guys decide you want to spend more aggressively so there's less profit to share and how do you balance that?
Nathan Barry
51:37>> Yeah, so one, like the same, all the transparency that you see on the outside, we have even more transparency on the inside. So for example,
51:47>> we have a full open book so everyone can see all the expenses, see what we're spending and everything. And we just are really upfront about all of the trade offs in the business. So we talk about this like short term versus long term and what the effects are with compounded growth and everything else. So I think of compensation in two different ways that kind of makes a quadrant. So I think of short term versus long term
52:15>> compensation. And then I think of guaranteed versus performance based. So short term guaranteed is salary, long term guaranteed is like 401(k) match, you know, retirement. Short
52:26>> term performance based is profit sharing and long term performance based is equity. And what I think that does is it makes this whole, like this matrix it's all covered and you're taken care of in each way. And the individual team member can get a feel for the trade offs that the business is making. So for example, I as a founder, I'm like, let's spend right now because let's get on the growth trajectory that we want on
52:51>> our path to 50,000,000 ARR, 100,000,000 ARR. And you don't want a team member be like, no, no, no. I want money in my pocket.
Nathan Latka
52:57Pocket sharing. Yeah.
Nathan Barry
52:58>> Yeah. And so by having them participate in each side of it, they get to live in that tension that you as a founder live in, and they go, Okay, yeah, let's invest now, because profit sharing will be bigger down the road, and because
53:15>> my equity is going to have more value down the road.
Nathan Latka
53:17So what portion of 58 companies, Nathan, besides your own equity, what portion of the companies do teammates own currently?
Nathan Barry
53:24>> Yeah, so I own 90% and the team pool is 10% of which 7% is currently allocated.
Nathan Latka
53:31That's great. That's great. Okay. And yeah, paid spend is growing drastically. I'm just looking at Ahrefs while we're doing this. I mean, you used to like may rank for like in paper three twenty five keywords and now it's at like four accents, like 1,200 keywords. So clearly you're running experiments there.
Nathan Barry
53:46>> Yes.
Nathan Latka
53:46Interesting. How much are you spending per month now on paid ads?
Nathan Barry
53:50>> I think about 400,000.
Nathan Latka
53:51Okay, interesting. How do you, I mean, is it working?
Nathan Barry
53:56>> It's working decently. There's a lot of things that we're having to figure out. We're able to drive a lot of free accounts, but one, for example, we found that our mobile experience isn't as good as it should be. And so, you know, inexpensive accounts to drive are mobile accounts. But if you don't have that a great in app mobile experience, then, you know, they're not going to convert or they're not going to have a good uptake.
54:20>> So there's a lot that we've been trying to figure out. The other thing is we've been, we're about to kick off some big new brand campaigns where we actually hired like a major marketing agency to produce like video brand ads for us.
Nathan Latka
54:33How interesting.
Nathan Barry
54:35>> We'll see how that goes.
Nathan Latka
54:37That's Why not not hire little videographers and send them to your creators and have them shoot like raw, a little blurry videos that seem like really real and it's a cook and it's splashing on the lens.
Nathan Barry
54:47>> Yeah, I mean, there's the whole, all kinds of different ways to do it. And I think we're just excited to see, actually, what's funny, so the agency we hired is Mekanism and they're based out of New York and Jason Harris who runs it, I don't know him very well, but we're both investors in the ghost town together.
Nathan Latka
55:07Oh, nice.
Nathan Barry
55:08>> And they do stuff for Alaska Airlines and Peloton and everybody else, you know. And so that's one of those things of sort of keep it in the family in that one case.
Acquisitions, Investments, and Capital Leverage
Nathan Latka
55:18Yeah, well, like that. And that brings me up to where I wanna wrap this up, you know, going back to your ladders of wealth creation that you've modeled time for money, your own services, product type services, selling products. And then there's this next level, which is, you know, not only Nathan is making money, like you are making money from ConvertKit, but your team members are too, and they're sort of capital leverage. And so, you know, you
55:40write your about your investments on your website, like, know what, I working with these people, they're my friends, I'm going give them capital and see what happens. Can you talk to me about that? Because I don't see that on the ladders of operations or a chart you've built. How are you thinking about literal capital leverage moving forward for Nathan Barry?
Nathan Barry
55:57>> Yeah, I think it's not on the chart because it's relatively new for me. If you look at my earnings, they trail, like ConvertKit's growth, like my earnings trailed out by a few years, right? That's something interesting that my wife and I talked about. It was only three years ago that we didn't really have The things were really tight. And so I think that's something that I'm learning a lot right now and is just what that investing
56:26>> looked like. Someone that I follow a lot in that space is Andrew Wilkinson from Tiny. It's just fascinating to see him deploy capital.
56:37>> And it's just been fun to read books like The Outsiders or Snowball about Warren Buffett or some of these other books of like, okay, wow. It's not just all angel investing and stuff like that. I have a decent number of angel investments. Not a lot, I think maybe nine.
56:56>> But what I'm trying to do more of now would be inspired by like what Andrew is doing or Warren Buffett style of like, great, can I buy 10% of a company? And then so like, there's an e commerce brand that I was able to do that with Which one? This They're called Harkla. They
57:18>> sell products for special needs and they just have incredible opportunities to grow. And then we acquired a minority share of a company called SparkLoop. So we're basically looking for what are these things? Where instead of buying a tiny percentage through an angel investment, we could buy 5%, 10%, 20%. And then it could become part of a portfolio that could eventually feed each other.
Nathan Latka
57:48When is the Nathan Barry ConvertKit rolling fund, but private equity version, not VC version launching?
Nathan Barry
57:55>> I don't know. Probably the biggest thing that I'm torn on right now is chasing after some of these fun opportunities. Like I have a real estate business here in Boise that I started with two friends, mainly because they had all this energy and the desire to like move up the ladders of wealth creation, but needed some more help and needed capital. And so to do that with them has been really, really fun. But then at the
58:19>> same time, all the opportunities in ConvertKit. Like let's say if we're valuing ConvertKit at 7x ARR, 8x ARR, something like that.
Nathan Latka
58:28I'd say that's conservative for even for you've built, yeah.
Nathan Barry
58:32>> Then you're looking at what it takes to add an additional million dollars in value, in enterprise value for ConvertKit versus what it takes to go making a million dollars somewhere else. And it's just an order of magnitude more effort to do it in real estate investing or something like that, because ConvertKit has so much momentum. And so it's an easy trap to fall into of like, Oh, I've made this money here, now let me go to
58:55>> this other thing. When if you just look at Kohl's- Leverage. Straight up leverage, then the answer is this has worked, so let's keep doing it. Put in more effort there, go faster. And so it's a balance between what's fun and like a little bit of a diversification and like, no, just keep doubling down on ConvertKit.
Nathan Latka
59:17Last question, Nathan, you sent out an LOI to buy a company this morning, which company was it for?
Nathan Barry
59:21>> Can't tell you.
Nathan Latka
59:24I thought that would be the answer. So let me back up. How do you go about finding companies you send LOIs to?
Nathan Barry
59:30>> Yeah, that's a good question. Markets So that we're spending into
59:38>> something that is a good fit, something that we hear a lot from our customer base of like, if we see integrations popping up a lot.
59:49>> If we look at say our three year roadmap and if there's something that we're planning to build, but it's a few years off, and then we see someone who is getting good traction in that space, right? Our customers are already using them. Then it's like, oh, we could accelerate a plan two or three years out if we buy them today. Especially when in any software company, engineering time is the single greatest constraint. And so there's so
60:19>> many opportunities to chase and you just have to take the Richard Branson quote of like, opportunities are like buses, there's always another one coming. And so you end up in a point where capital is more available than like skilled engineering time to apply to problems. And that's when acquisitions start to become interesting of like, okay, I can accelerate this plan
60:42>> for a million dollars rather than having to spin up a whole new engineering team and then spend a year building it.
Nathan Latka
60:49Guys, there you have it. Nathan Barry 2005. A long journey when his parents dropped him off, he showed up with the van out for the $120 of woodworking sales quickly got into college early said give me to do list of what I got to get done then landed a $10,000 contract marketing contract ended up dropping out of school to pursue that and eventually turned those professional services goods into a couple thousand dollars a month. But it really
61:10changed in 2015. When he started really focusing on ConvertKit community building and that first team retreat in 2016 when they paid out their first profit sharing to employees of $100,000 Now, 58 ConvertKit team members strong focus on building the creator economy, they're empowering these creators in many different ways and they continue to drive growth 19,000,000 last year and run rate up to $25,000,000 run rate today. Totally bootstrapped. Nathan Barry, thanks for taking us to the top.
Nathan Barry
61:35>> Thanks for having me.
Nathan Latka
61:36Boom, guys. Cut. Nathan, what'd you think, man?